3/5 shells xxx
Petite Abeille, 401 E 20th St, New York, NY.
I heard about this place from a friend – a recommendation for an all-you-can-eat mussels night. A deal that motivates one to eat until you can’t eat anymore, and then keep eating. You can always diet tomorrow, right? Right.
You can’t indulge in all-you-can-eat mussels by yourself, so I went with a few friends. (Photos courtesy of friend nomalicious – Thanks!) First impressions of a restaurant can really flavor the rest of the meal, and Petite Abeille was warm and comforting. Mussels night is on Wednesdays, and there was a balance of busy and bustle at the bar offset with relatively quiet (mussel) eaters at the tables. Nowhere did it feel overly crowded and I never thought anyone was being pushy or cold. The crowd waxed and waned as we had our mussels – you could tell when New Yorkers were finished with happy hour and then again when New Yorkers were heading out for dinner.
For $25, the special includes one draft (chosen by the restaurant) and as many rounds of mussels as you want. Naturally, you can only order one flavor at a time. We went for 3 – one for each of us. There were five total flavors on the menu, and we tried one of each before the night was over.
Our first round included the moules marinieres (white wine celery garlic broth), moules poulette (creamy white wine and shallot sauce), and moules rasta (Jamaican curry sauce and crisp apple).
The mussels arrived, each portion filling a large, steaming, deep pot. Too deep! As much as I appreciated the large serving of the shellfish of the day, I could not reach the bottom of the pot for the first layer or so of mussels to savor the sauce, and there wasn’t enough sauce for the mussels. Still, between the mussels and the vegetables, the first pot was plenty filling.
But of course, we still wanted to try the others! So we ordered an order of each of the flavors that we did not order before – the moules grand-mere (creamy beer sauce and bacon essence) and the moules sergio (tomato tarragon sauce). As a vegetarian for Lent, I couldn’t try the bacon flavor, but the other was quite good. These portions were smaller (thank goodness!), and the mussels were juicier and fatter. We speculated that we must have gotten a fresh batch… A good way to end the night though – mussels until we couldn’t eat any more – not even a single extra little mussel, and all of these juicy with easily accessible sauce. All of the mussels that evening should have been like these.
What will bring you back: A lust for mussels in sheer quantity. It’s a great deal if you can indeed eat a lot of mussels. Even if you can finish 2 pots (which is really like 1.5 pots) and drink a beer, it’s worth the price ($3.25 extra compared to a normal serving of just mussels and fries).
What you might not like: The flavors were not that distinctive, and the quality of the mussels were inconsistent. Perhaps they would be better on a not-unlimited night.